Sam Johnston - NAIA Gold Glove Third Baseman

2012
Izaac Garsez - 1st Team All-America
Jarel Lewis - Honorable Mention All-America

2011
Izaac Garsez - Honorable Mention All-America
Mitch Dame - NAIA Gold Glove Pitcher

2010
Diego Robles - Honorable Mention All-America
Ben Rosen - Honorable Mention All-America

2007
Luke Howarth - NAIA Gold Glove Outfielder

2006
Casey Oliver - Honorable Mention All-America
Greg Stalling - Honorable Mention All-America
Pat Burke - Honorable Mention All-America
Jason Roach - Honorable Mention All-America

2005
Charlie Strandlund - Honorable Mention All-America

2004
Greg Stalling - Honorable Mention All-America

2003
Darren Uranga - Honorable Mention All-America
Todd Howell - Honorable Mention All-America
Dustin Garcia - Honorable Mention All-America
Greg Stalling - Honorable Mention All-America

2002
Scott Skeen - Honorable Mention All-America
Chris Eggleston - Honorable Mention All-America
Patrick Gonzalez - NAIA World Series Gold Glove Award / NAIA World Series All-Tournament
Darren Uranga - NAIA World Series All-Tournament
Nick Williams - NAIA World Series All-Tournament
Cory Acklus - NAIA World Series All-Tournament

2001
Branden Florence - Honorable Mention All-America
Scott Skeen - Honorable Mention All-America
Jason Stefani - Honorable Mention All-America
Casey Macomb - Honorable Mention All-America

2000
Gavin Gosz - Honorable Mention All-America
Chad Hartley - Honorable Mention All-America
Michael Kraemer - Honorable Mention All-America
Casey Macomb - Honorable Mention All-America
Ross Mitchell - Honorable Mention All-America

1999
Greg Schelhaas - Second-Team All-America
James Atwood - Second-Team All-America
Branden Florence - Honorable Mention All-America / NAIA World Series All-Tournament
Luke Hays Honorable Mention All-America
Jon Lehman NAIA World Series All-Tournament
Aaron Smith NAIA World Series All-Tournament
Brandon Mattingly NAIA World Series Gold Glove Award / NAIA World Series All-Tournament

1998
Levi Lacey - First-Team All-America
Aaron Smith - Second-Team All-America
Jon Lehman - NAIA World Series All-Tournament
Steve Barningham - NAIA World Series All-Tournament
Denny Gilich - NAIA World Series All-Tournament
Luke Hays - NAIA World Series All-Tournament

1997
Levi Lacey - First-Team All-America
Greg Schelhaas - Honorable Mention All-America

1996
Jason Simontacchi - Second-Team All-America
Tim Onofrei - Honorable Mention All-America
Bill Oliver - Honorable Mention All-America
Bobby Mick - Honorable Mention All-America

1995
Tim Onofrei - Honorable Mention All-America

1994
Kurt Alderman - Honorable Mention All-America
Brady Swallow - Honorable Mention All-America

1993
Al Mendiola - Honorable Mention All-America

1992
Craig Nixon - Honorable Mention All-America

1989
Brad Stone - Honorable Mention All-America

1987
Doug Euper - Honorable Mention All-America