CALDWELL, Idaho — No. 3 College of Idaho turned a heavyweight matchup into a statement Saturday, pulling away from No. 2 Montana Tech 35-19 at Simplot Stadium in a battle of two previously unbeaten teams.
The Yotes never trailed, but Montana Tech repeatedly threatened to swing the momentum. College of Idaho answered every challenge, using explosive plays early and a grinding second half to hand the Orediggers their first loss of the season.
Caden Young connected with Travis Marieiro for a 54-yard touchdown on the Yotes' opening scoring drive, and Young later found Trey Gibson for a 40-yard touchdown to put College of Idaho ahead 14-3 late in the first quarter. Montana Tech answered with a 31-yard field goal before the quarter ended.
The Orediggers opened the second quarter with a 2-yard touchdown run by Jamal Cariglia, cutting the deficit to 14-10. The Yotes responded immediately. Young found Marieiro for 35 yards to set up the drive, and Rylie Byington finished it with a 15-yard touchdown run to push the lead back to 21-10.
Montana Tech refused to go away.
Casey Kautzman connected on a 47-yard field goal with 1:05 left in the half, and Jarrett Wilson hit Colby Martinez for a 58-yard touchdown with 2 seconds remaining. The failed 2-point conversion left the Orediggers within two points.
Then College of Idaho delivered one of the wildest sequences of the afternoon.
With no time remaining, Trezell Patterson fielded the ensuing kickoff and raced 84 yards for a touchdown, sending the Simplot Stadium crowd into a frenzy. Josh Horn's extra point gave the Yotes a 28-19 halftime advantage.
College of Idaho seized control to open the second half.
The Yotes marched 73 yards on 11 plays, consuming 5:29 off the clock. Young converted key plays with his legs and arm before Byington powered into the end zone from 1 yard out to make it 35-19.
From there, the College of Idaho defense repeatedly slammed the door.
Montana Tech managed to move the ball, but the Yotes came up with stops when they mattered most. Aleki Noyes recorded a sack and helped anchor a defense that held the Orediggers scoreless after halftime. Montana Tech drove inside the College of Idaho 10-yard line twice in the fourth quarter but came away empty both times, including a fourth-down stop at the 6-yard line with 3:22 remaining.
The Yotes then turned to Byington to close it out, grinding out six straight runs for 35 yards and converting a third-and-3 to keep the clock moving until the final seconds.
Young completed 14 of 22 passes for 214 yards and two touchdowns, while Byington rushed for 103 yards and two scores on 23 carries. Marieiro led the Yotes with six catches for 121 yards and a touchdown, while Gibson added two catches for 50 yards and a score.
Aleki Noyes led the defensive effort with eight tackles, including a sack and two tackles for loss. Kessler Fjellman added a sack and 1½ tackles for loss, while Elton Saole-Su'e recorded five tackles and two tackles for loss. The Yotes finished with three sacks and four tackles for loss as a unit.
The Yotes finished with 359 yards of total offense and converted 9 of 14 third downs. Their defense held Montana Tech to 322 yards and just 13% third-down efficiency.
The victory improves College of Idaho to 4-0 on the season, while Montana Tech falls to 4-1.
The Yotes return to action next week at home as they host Simpson University for Homecoming.