CALDWELL, Idaho – The College of Idaho men's basketball team had unfinished business Tuesday night, and the Yotes delivered. After falling to crosstown rival Northwest Nazarene University in the opening game of the United Heritage Mayors' Cup, the Purple and Gold returned home determined to even the score, battling their way to a thrilling 65-62 victory inside J.A. Albertson Center.
The win splits the 2026 Mayor's Cup series at one game apiece, with each team defending its home court in the annual rivalry. Dating back to the 1933-34 season, Idaho's oldest collegiate basketball rivalry added another memorable chapter as 1,608 fans watched the Yotes improve to 5-1 on the season.
Tucker Tiddens led the charge for College of Idaho, finishing with a game-high 22 points and seven rebounds. Tiddens shot 6-of-12 from the field, connected on two three-pointers and knocked down eight free throws, including two crucial makes in the final seconds to help secure the victory.
The opening half saw both teams trade momentum as Northwest Nazarene jumped out to an early advantage. The Yotes responded with contributions from their bench, including a three-pointer from David Kludt and a dunk from Jackson Rogers that helped erase the early deficit. After NNU briefly regained the lead late in the half, Tiddens connected from beyond the arc with 51 seconds remaining to put the Yotes back in front. Four late free throws extended the advantage, sending College of Idaho into the break leading 35-29.
The intensity only increased after halftime. College of Idaho stretched its lead to eight early in the second half, but the Nighthawks responded with a scoring run of their own. NNU eventually grabbed a 48-42 advantage with just over 12 minutes remaining, forcing the Yotes to battle their way back into the contest.
Tiddens sparked the comeback with a three-pointer at the 10:20 mark before Rey Johnston followed with another from deep to even the score at 48. The two teams continued exchanging baskets down the stretch, setting the stage for a dramatic finish.
With 4:03 remaining, Conner Sheets drilled a three-pointer to give College of Idaho a 58-57 advantage before adding a layup to extend the lead to three. NNU answered with a three-pointer to tie the game at 60, but Sheets delivered once again, connecting from beyond the arc with 1:19 remaining to put the Yotes ahead 63-60.
After the Nighthawks cut the deficit to one, Tiddens came up with a critical block on a late NNU layup attempt before sinking two free throws with 11 seconds remaining. The Yotes held on for the 65-62 victory, defending their home court in another exciting installment of the rivalry.
Sheets provided a major spark off the bench, finishing with 11 points on 4-of-8 shooting, including three three-pointers. Dougie Peoples also contributed nine points and a team-high five assists, while Kairi Shepherd added six rebounds and four assists. Reece Sasser-Gunson pulled down a team-high 11 rebounds to help anchor the Yotes on the glass.
Despite shooting 32.8 percent from the field, College of Idaho capitalized on opportunities at the free-throw line, converting 17-of-23 attempts compared to NNU's 6-of-12 performance. The Yotes also held a 26-16 advantage in bench scoring and turned 10 Nighthawk turnovers into 13 points.
Northwest Nazarene was led by Andrew King's 20 points and seven rebounds, while Jayden Smoot added 14 points.
The victory provided a fitting response to last week's 90-86 setback in Nampa, where Peoples erupted for 36 points but the Yotes fell just short. This time, it was a balanced team effort, timely shooting and late-game execution that pushed College of Idaho across the finish line.
With the two rivals splitting the 2026 United Heritage Mayors' Cup series, each program walks away with a home-court victory, adding another competitive chapter to a rivalry spanning more than nine decades.